New York filmmaker, Morris Farbstein II, travels to the town of Sinnaville, Mississippi to shoot his graduate thesis documentary about a flamboyantly gay antique dealer and community theatre actor named Cesar Nutley Willingham IV who’s causing a local and federal controversy with his new mailbox, made and given to him for his 33rd birthday by his childhood lesbian artist friend, Kymeleon Cockerham. Some see the mailbox as beautiful art. Others see it as pure evil, such as Brother Oral Buchanan, pastor of The First Church of Divine Righteousness, who spearheads a campaign against the mailbox, Cesar, and all people like him. In the end, the filmmaker discovers more than intended.